Businesses are struggling to translate artificial intelligence (AI) initiatives into measurable, scaled results. While Chief AI Officers (CAIOs) generally understand where AI creates value or falls short, a new IBM Institute for Business Value study reveals that a mere 18% of these leaders have control over the crucial investment decisions needed to drive action.
The global research, based on a survey of over 1,600 CAIOs and equivalent AI leaders, found that only 18% of respondents have full control over AI investment decisions.
This disconnect is reflected in how organizations approach business reorganization and resource allocation. Fewer than a third of surveyed CAIOs report that AI is transforming their business models, impacting what the company sells, how it prices products, or how it generates revenue. Similarly, only 29% of respondents indicate that their organizations quickly adjust decisions and resources when AI performance insights highlight opportunities for improved outcomes.

Research Methodology
The IBM Institute for Business Value, in collaboration with Oxford Economics, surveyed 1,667 senior executives responsible for AI strategy, governance, implementation, and value realization within companies. This group includes Chief AI Officers (CAIOs), Chief Data and AI Officers (CDAIOs), AI leads, and equivalent leaders, collectively referred to as “CAIOs” for this study.
The survey was conducted from April to June 2026 across 33 countries and 20 industries, examining respondents’ AI priorities, AI investment management, and AI operationalization. Additional analysis focused on organizational behaviors associated with better enterprise outcomes in areas such as governance, decision rights, workflow integration, operating model design, value management, transformation execution, and business model innovation.
Understanding AI Value for the Enterprise
Joan Wright, IBM’s Senior Vice President of Transformation and Operations, noted in the study’s foreword, “Only a select few leaders have a broad view of how AI creates value for the enterprise. However, the results they [AI leaders] are held accountable for often depend on decisions made by others. This means successful AI leadership requires more than technical expertise or operational oversight; it demands building evidence, influencing decisions, and measuring success.”
The study highlights a group of high-impact CAIOs whose organizations exhibit superior performance. These leaders report that 63% of their AI projects deliver measurable business results, compared to 43% among all other CAIOs. Furthermore, 49% of their projects move from pilot to production, versus 33% for others. They also scale successful initiatives across the enterprise in an average of eight months, compared to 13.5 months for other CAIOs. These outcomes are linked to differences in how organizations manage AI autonomy and control, redesign workflows, and make evidence-based investment decisions.
Other Key Study Findings
- CAIOs Balance Greater AI Autonomy with Enhanced Control: While 48% of CAIOs report that AI agents initiate and execute actions within workflows, 75% experience delays in AI-driven actions due to regulatory requirements, risks, or compliance issues. Although 73% of respondents have identified areas where human oversight is essential, only 61% state that AI decision-making rights are clearly defined and consistently applied. High-impact CAIOs are nearly four times more likely to be able to quickly pause, adjust, or redirect AI systems without disrupting operations. Concurrently, 96% of these high-impact CAIOs report that AI outputs can automatically trigger actions, compared to 40% of other CAIOs.
- Organizations Scale AI Faster Than Rebuilding Business Around It: Only 32% believe AI is transforming their business model, while 35% of CAIOs state it primarily augments existing models, and 26% expect it to transform the model but have not yet made the necessary shifts. A significant 71% of CAIOs believe their organizations risk falling behind competitors in AI transformation. CAIOs identify workflows and business processes as the top priority for change. Nearly all high-impact CAIOs assert that AI is embedded directly into workflows, compared to 59% of others.
- High-Impact CAIOs Redirect Investments Based on AI Performance: Just 31% of all CAIOs consider clear thresholds for stopping AI initiatives critical for success. Forty percent of CAIOs note that decisions are debated when performance insights reveal opportunities, but action is delayed. In contrast, 94% of high-impact CAIOs state they use business results to determine which initiatives receive additional funding and talent, and which do not. These CAIOs are 96% more likely to halt or reduce investment in initiatives that fail to deliver results, even if those initiatives have executive backing, compared to 46% of others. Furthermore, 95% of high-impact CAIOs report reinvesting AI-generated productivity gains into higher-value transformation, compared to 44% of other respondents.
The full report is available at: https://www.ibm.com/thought-leadership/institute-business-value/en-us/report/2026-caio









